A Slice of Paradise in Summerland Key

A Slice of Paradise in Summerland Key
4 / 5
50 reviews

24458 Overseas Hwy, Summerland Key, FL 33042-4613, Summerland Key

Overview

Cuisine
  • Pizza
  • Italian
  • Vegetarian Friendly
Features
  • Delivery
  • Takeout
  • Wheelchair Accessible
Good for
  • Kids
  • Families witd children

Restaurant Hours

Monday

11:00 am

Wednesday

11:00 am

Friday

11:00 am

Sunday

11:00 am

Can you sit in.......

No, but there are picnic tables outside by the water.

Do they do gluten free pizza?

I'm not sure, but the pizza is awesome!

Review

Add rating restaurant:
A Slice of Paradise
SH
Stacy Hoadley
google
11.21.2024
5/5

Amazing people. Amazing prices. Fast delivery and take out. FREE DELIVERY!!! Beautiful location to eat there.

A Slice of Paradise
SN
Stefan Nöken
google
11.15.2018
5/5

Really good pizza. Smells great. Friendly people and fair price. Wonderful view if you sit outside.

A Slice of Paradise
DS
Don Smith
google
11.12.2018
5/5

Stopped in on our way back to Kentucky from key west, great pizza, super friendly service, was a great way to finish the day!

A Slice of Paradise
SM
Steven Mauritzen
google
11.10.2018
1/5

The pizza was absolutely terrible,too much cheese,terrible service ,I do not recommend going there there food is terrible

A Slice of Paradise
MC
Marley Claridge
google
11.09.2018
5/5

They have VEGAN CHEESE! AND the food is good too!

A Slice of Paradise
LA
Longhaul Adventures
google
09.17.2018
5/5

Good food. Good vibes. They actually thanked me for choosing their establishment as our dinner choice. When was the last time you heard that from restaurant employees? Well done, crew and thanks for the good eats!!

A Slice of Paradise
VJ
Vineet Joshi
google
09.09.2018
5/5

Service is fast and staff is super friendly! Loved this place!!!

A Slice of Paradise
JO
JAVIER OSPINA
google
08.17.2018
5/5

love this beach

A Slice of Paradise
BC
Brice Cook
google
07.27.2018
5/5

Great tasting pizza. Love the location very close to my house.

A Slice of Paradise
MM
Marianna M
google
07.12.2018
5/5

Five stars for the service, the quality food, the friendly and efficient staff plus they are just rocking it!

A Slice of Paradise
SW
Steve Welch
google
05.07.2018
5/5

Um, this place is great. Kids loved it. Had it twice in 4 days Fair price, awesome ingredients like mango and other weird fun stuff, and its not greasy. Pizza and garlic sticks for less than $25. Use the slice app and save a fee bucks.

A Slice of Paradise
CH
Candice Howard
google
04.27.2018
5/5

Shrimp alfredo pizza! So good!

A Slice of Paradise
SV
Solangel Verde
google
04.21.2018
5/5

This place is perfect. Great pizza and amazing service. They made a mistake on my order and immediately sent the correct item. Delicious!

A Slice of Paradise
TB
Theresa-Dawn Bright
google
03.26.2018
5/5

Great philly cheesesteak pizza

A Slice of Paradise
AB
Angie Bohanan
google
03.25.2018
5/5

GREAT PIZZA

A Slice of Paradise
BB
Brandi Bayha
google
10.24.2017
5/5

Great food with nice outdoor seating

A Slice of Paradise
BP
Brenda Poland
google
10.16.2017
5/5

Really great pizza! You can tell they use high-quality mozzarella!

A Slice of Paradise
ls
lady sonja wilson
google
09.21.2017
1/5

Slice of Paradise is walking distance from my home. It not worth it. Customer service has gone from reasonable to bad just like the pizza.

A Slice of Paradise
UT
UncleMike TV
google
09.18.2017
4/5

Would have given 5 stars but every time I order a hamburger rare or medium-rare it comes out well done, and dry as the sahara desert, I'm going to call in my order next time I use the internet now to make my order it is easier for me that way, The drivers that bring me my order are very good and polite. They always leave my food at the door then text me to tell me its there, they have to cause its no contact cause of the virus that has us all scared out of our wits.

A Slice of Paradise
Denise
google
08.12.2017
1/5

Tried a couple times. Subs greasy. Cheese pizza just has no flavor. The cheese is not what it should be. They are friendly and prompt, but in the end you can taste the quality. Pizza works in Big Pine is where I will go to now.

A Slice of Paradise
KO
Kirsten Olsen
google
07.21.2017
5/5

Just moved to Cudjoe away from our favorite pizza place and stumbled across Paradise. We have a new favorite!!!!!

A Slice of Paradise
MA
Miss Andrea Reads
google
07.02.2017
5/5

We called ahead our order when we left Key West. They had our pizza hot and ready. We ordered hand tossed and garlic breadsticks. This was the best pizza we had in a long time! There is no indoor seating but there are a few picnic tables outside on the canal with umbrellas and lights. Super great experience!

A Slice of Paradise
BS
Brandon Silvers
google
06.12.2017
5/5

I ordered the Hawaiian pizza. Not only was it delicious, but the process through the mobile app was seamless and they offered a diacount. Thanks for making it wasy!

A Slice of Paradise
rc
robert c
google
04.16.2017
1/5

I ordered a pizza with double sausage and double mushroom. What I got was about less than half a regular pizza place would put on. I was like maybe they just screwed up. I ordered from them again and told them what happened. They said they would take care of it. Same thing. I thought maybe that's all they give. Once more I tried. This time triple Toppings. This time I told the driver to wait till I opened the pizza. I asked her what she thought this order was? She said a Sausage and mushroom their topical order. I asked if she thought if it was a double she said no. I told her that it was supposed to be a triple order. She said I wondered why it cost so much. She said that she would tell the boss and he would take care of it. It has been months now and I am still waiting..

A Slice of Paradise
HS
Heather Scott
google
02.25.2017
5/5

Always come to this pizza place, it's so delicious

A Slice of Paradise
parkmann1
google
01.08.2017
5/5

Best pizza view I've ever experienced and the pizza was amazing as were the staff

A Slice of Paradise
CM
Charles Myers
google
11.07.2016
5/5

The girl that prepared our pizza's was the daughter of a well known Pizza Master, my thanks to you Dad, her pizza's were well above average they were wonderfully delicious, good experience would recommend

A Slice of Paradise
DH
D. Hernandez
google
11.07.2016
5/5

Love this place.

A Slice of Paradise
SS
Sarah Sim
google
11.05.2016
4/5

It was a good pizza but the chicken was not seasonet. The view was great .

A Slice of Paradise
Ok
Omar kamall
google
10.27.2016
5/5

Building look rough on the outside but the pizza was excellent. Definitely go there.

A Slice of Paradise
NF
Norman Fourte
google
10.21.2016
4/5

Pizza is great! Wings... not so much.

A Slice of Paradise
GD
Guy D. Tervene
google
10.11.2016
1/5

Do yourself a favor, do not waste your time or money on their chicken wings; no flavor and way overpriced. Also, chicken wings came-in floating in an inch of grease.Their pizza is just average.

A Slice of Paradise
SP
Slice’o Paradise
google
09.01.2016
5/5

We deliver from Bay Point/Bluewater to big pine. we make everything in house and have our fresh produce and ingredients delivered three times a week. we have vegan and healthy options. We are open from 11 AM to 9:30 PM Sunday through Thursday and 11 AM to 11 PM Friday and Saturday

A Slice of Paradise
Anarcheaologist
google
08.06.2016
5/5

Chicken parmesan sub was awesome. Good prices, cool people and an excellent view!

A Slice of Paradise
NS
Nicolas Solis
google
08.02.2016
5/5

Awesome.light setting and great pizza to go with it. The crew was ready evem up to closing time. Kudos

A Slice of Paradise
MG
Mike G
google
06.18.2016
4/5

Good pizza at a fair price. Outdoor seating only, but it's in the shade with a canal view.

A Slice of Paradise
RP
Rocky Perry
google
05.26.2016
5/5

Very fast. Very hot. Very friendly. Very yummy!! Highly recommended!

A Slice of Paradise
JC
Jody C.
google
05.26.2016
4/5

Good food.

A Slice of Paradise
MC
Michael Conchscooter
google
05.16.2016
5/5

Best pizza in the Lower Keys especially if you want something more interesting than the usual pepperoni and tomato sauce.

A Slice of Paradise
BT
Bill Tosney
google
04.22.2016
4/5

For what it is, it really is a slice of paradise. Pizza is good and I've gone back for sandwiches many times. Great value too!!

A Slice of Paradise
TW
The Wandering Sailor
google
04.17.2016
5/5

For a local or tourist this is a pretty cool little spot to go for your basic pizza shop foods with a little extra. You can even bring a dinghy or small boat right up to the seawall behind the hut. Everything I've personally had there was delicious and properly cooked. Staff is always friendly and helpful so that's a plus. You can sit outside and eat under the trees next to the canal as well.

A Slice of Paradise
MM
Mason Mccrary
google
04.11.2016
5/5

Really like their food. On time delivery and it just is good

A Slice of Paradise
hM
hader Mora
google
04.09.2016
5/5

Good pizza option on the road

A Slice of Paradise
KM
Karina Mendieta
google
03.26.2016
5/5

How great pizza I got!!! This is our second time ordering during this lock down and we absolutely love it!! Services was faster than advertised and crew is so friendly! Also the food itself was delicious and the sizes and prices are just right!!! Will definitely stop by when all this pass!!! Thank you!!!!

A Slice of Paradise
CS
Camila Soares Belmonte
google
03.18.2016
4/5

Large four cheese pizza is delicious.

A Slice of Paradise
CC
Chevi Caskey
google
03.03.2016
5/5

Best pizza in town The food might be a few bucks more than the other pizza shops but 100% worth it for the fresh ingredients They do not use frozen dough, flavorless sauce or canned mushrooms. You can definitely tell this place takes pride in the food they serve

A Slice of Paradise
SS
SANDY SENICK
google
02.19.2016
2/5

Expensive price sub par qualitydinner

A Slice of Paradise
MA
Matthew Arthurs
google
02.04.2016
5/5

Stayed at Sugarloaf Key, had this delivered and it was super fast, accurate and delicious. Used the "slice" app and saved 3$. Estimated delivery was 30 to 50 min but got it in 24.

A Slice of Paradise
KS
Kat Standard
google
02.01.2016
5/5

Really good pretty cheap great views definitely will come again

A Slice of Paradise
BC
Broward County Chamber of Commerce
google
01.12.2016
1/5

Pizza, Philly cheese steak and poppers were tasty but paying 12.00 for each order of wings only to see 6 wings in each order ruined my experience. Everyone wanted to try the wings, but 2.00 each is more than what you would pay on NYC or on rodeo drive and they don't know how to cook wings. They bake them.

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 13057449718

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!